Attorney Alexander Alekseevich Fishchuk
Krasnodar Regional Bar Association · Moscow, Zubovsky Boulevard, 15, building 2 · Khamovniki, Central Administrative Okrug · Park Kultury Metro Station
+7 (495) 295-09-11 · office@fishchuk.pro · fishchuk.pro/en/services/subsidiary-liability-defense/
Save as PDF
Service 2 · Subsidiary Liability and Personal Assets

Defense of Personal Assets Against Subsidiary Liability

Defense counsel enters corporate insolvency disputes in the Russian Federation (RF) under one governing standard: verifiable facts instead of unrealistic promises. Across commercial courts, complete dismissal of petitions against a controlling person of a debtor (CPD) occurs in 39 to 48 percent of cases. Effective protection of personal wealth in Russian rubles (RUB) relies on early structural prevention, exhaustion of hostile creditor incentives, and lawful debt discharge. Paragraph 58 of the Supreme Court Review of June 18, 2025 confirmed discharge mechanisms even against major Federal Tax Service (FTS) arrears.

Quentin Massys, The Moneylender and His Wife, 1514: gold scales, coins on the table, the wife looking up from her prayer book
Quentin Massys · The Moneylender and His Wife · 1514
52%
Granted subsidiary liability claims in 2024
commercial court statistics
RUB 703 million
Discharged in the Rasoyan case under paragraph 58 of the Supreme Court Review of June 18, 2025
Case A63-1714/2020
from RUB 500,000
Base cost of defense per stage
Method

Three principles

Truth instead of promises

Defense strategy excludes unrealistic assurances of guaranteed dismissal where judicial statistics show full exoneration in only 39 to 48 percent of insolvency disputes. Every mandate begins with an objective assessment of evidentiary exposure, procedural probabilities at each instance, and realistic boundaries of legal protection.

Three parallel logics

Comprehensive defense combines corporate governance and transparent documentation years prior to financial distress with procedural exhaustion of creditor litigation incentives during insolvency. For individuals already adjudicated liable, structured personal bankruptcy opens the statutory discharge window established by paragraph 58 of the June 18, 2025 Review.

Defense of the family perimeter

Assets held by a spouse, children, or extended relatives form an independent perimeter frequently targeted through marital share allocation and clawback petitions. Counsel challenges unfounded execution levies, defends acquisitions made by good-faith counterparties, and rebuts allegations of sham or collusive property transfers.

Discharging subsidiary liability through personal insolvency is an established judicial mechanism under paragraph 58 of the June 18, 2025 Supreme Court Review. In the landmark Rasoyan ruling, commercial courts discharged RUB 703 million in unpaid obligations previously assessed by the FTS.
Chain

Cascade of CPD liability

The trajectory from ordinary operations to subsidiary liability and lawful discharge under paragraph 58 of the June 18, 2025 Review in case A63-1714/2020.

1 Company ordinary operations 2 Debt / losses ▸ prevention window 3 Bankruptcy supervision 4 Subsidiary liability claim 52% granted 5 CPD bifurcation 6a Personal bankruptcy ▸ paragraph 58: discharge 6b Enforcement proceedings asset seizure
Defense window: prevention and discharge Point of no return: bankruptcy Attack stage on the CPD
Client inquiries

Real situations

Summarized scenarios reflect recurring subsidiary liability inquiries from 2024 to 2026 without disclosing confidential client names.

What it includes

Specific actions

Terms and cost

From RUB 500,000 per stage

Exact engagement terms and stage fees are determined following a preliminary diagnostic audit of the insolvency case file and disputed transactions.

Defense in a bankruptcy dispute
From engagement to completion of judicial proceedings, typically spanning 18 to 36 months.
Preventive asset protection
Structured project work spanning from 3 months to 1 year prior to corporate triggers.
Base cost
From RUB 500,000 per procedural stage, finalized after reviewing the commercial court docket and evidentiary materials.
Evidence base

Detailed materials on the topic

Published analytical reviews examine commercial court statistics, statutory presumptions, and verified defense strategies for corporate executives, shareholders, and chief accountants.

Longread · 23 minutes
Subsidiary Liability 2024-2025: Statistics, Owner Defense
Read →
Longread · 22 minutes
Personal Risks of the Executive and Chief Accountant 2025-2026
Read →
Longread · 7 minutes
Director's Subsidiary Liability in 2026: Protection of Personal Property
Read →
Longread · 30 minutes
Subsidiary Liability of Controlling Persons: How to Protect Assets
Read →
Frequently asked questions

Most common inquiries

?When does subsidiary liability of a director or shareholder arise?
Subsidiary liability arises when a bankrupt debtor lacks sufficient assets to satisfy creditors or when proceedings terminate due to absent procedural funding. Under Article 61.10 of Federal Law 127-FZ, exposure covers anyone who directed corporate decisions within three years before insolvency signs appeared. Primary statutory grounds include causing insolvency under Article 61.11 and failing to file a timely debtor petition under Article 61.12. Outside bankruptcy, creditors pursue controlling persons of an inactive Limited Liability Company (LLC) struck from the USRLE under Article 3(3.1) of the LLC Law.
?Will the only housing be taken away under subsidiary liability?
Under Article 446 of the Civil Procedure Code of the RF, statutory enforcement immunity generally shields a debtor's sole residential property from seizure. However, under Constitutional Court Resolution 15-P of April 26, 2021, courts may approve replacement housing where premises substantially exceed reasonable residential standards. Immunity is also contested if creditors trace acquisition funds directly to misappropriated corporate assets, requiring individual evidentiary verification.
?Will subsidiary liability be discharged after the personal bankruptcy of an individual?
Under paragraph 58 of the Supreme Court Review of June 18, 2025, personal insolvency courts may discharge subsidiary liability upon confirming good-faith conduct. In the Rasoyan ruling in case A63-1714/2020, commercial courts discharged RUB 703 million previously owed to the FTS. Because relief is never automatic, defense counsel must build a complete evidentiary record of procedural cooperation and absence of asset concealment.
?How many years later can one be held subsidiarily liable?
Under Article 61.14(5) of Federal Law 127-FZ, applicants may petition within three years after discovering statutory grounds and within three years of bankruptcy adjudication. An outer ten-year limitation runs from the underlying disputed acts, extendable by up to two additional years only upon proven valid cause. Because limitation periods do not run from formal resignation, former directors remain accountable for decisions taken during their actual corporate tenure.
?Does subsidiary liability extend to a spouse's property?
Creditors may petition to divide common marital property and levy execution against the debtor spouse's allocated share under family and insolvency statutes. Conversely, separate property confirmed by premarital title, inheritance, gift, or a timely marital agreement remains shielded from personal liability claims against the other spouse. Executing a transparent marital property agreement well before corporate financial distress therefore acts as a necessary preventive safeguard.
?How is subsidiary liability calculated and shared?
Under Article 61.11(11) of Federal Law 127-FZ, quantum for causing insolvency equals the aggregate unpaid register, post-register, and current creditor obligations. Courts reduce that sum where the defense proves that actual financial harm attributable to the respondent was substantially smaller than total debt. Multiple controlling persons bear joint and several liability under Article 61.11(8), whereas untimely filing liability under Article 61.12(2) covers only subsequent debts.
?How much does subsidiary liability defense cost?
Representation starts from RUB 500,000 per procedural stage under either a fixed retainer or a combined fee structure incorporating a documented result component. Final project pricing depends on total asserted creditor claims, whether proceedings run inside or outside corporate insolvency, and the number of parallel clawback disputes.

Describe the situation

Urgent inquiries concerning filed subsidiary liability petitions receive priority review during business hours, and every communication is protected by statutory attorney-client privilege.

Initial Fixed-Fee Mandates (Article 25 of Federal Law 63-FZ, Value Added Tax (VAT) exempt): Spoken audio consultation (30 minutes, without document review): RUB 5,000 · Spoken video strategy session (60 minutes, without prior document review): RUB 15,000 · Independent document review with a written legal opinion in PDF (up to 100 pages, 2 business days): RUB 25,000. View full tariff schedule →

Document review with a written legal opinion in PDF format is a standalone service (RUB 25,000). Files may also be sent via Telegram Bot @fishchuk_pravo_bot, Telegram @afischuk, Max +7 (926) 004-78-37, or office@fishchuk.pro.

Signature of Attorney Alexander Alekseevich Fishchuk
Attorney Alexander Alekseevich Fishchuk
Office
Moscow, Zubovsky Boulevard, 15, building 2 · Khamovniki, Central Administrative Okrug · Park Kultury Metro Station
Monday to Friday 10:00-19:00 · by appointment