Fees and engagement models

Pricing for business defense

The budget is calibrated to the mathematical expectation of losses — the realistic estimate of the damage the client may incur — rather than to procedural presence in court. A reasonable defense budget is 5-15% of that expected loss; the remaining economic value is captured through a success fee on amounts preserved.

All fees are stated in Russian rubles (RUB) and are exempt from value-added tax, while representation is conducted remotely across Russia and in person in Moscow.

Bar Registry
23/5500
Krasnodar Regional Bar Association, since 2016
Certificate
No. 6169
Issued 23 December 2016 · Federal Advocate Register
Experience
24 years
Audit and finance since 2002; legal practice since 2008
Open Archive
260+
Published case analyses on Pravorub legal portal
01 · Initial Consultation & Third Opinion

Oral consultation and independent third opinion

Three distinct formats for the initial engagement: a spoken audio consultation, a one-hour video strategy session, and an independent third opinion with examination of case materials and a written legal opinion in PDF format. Full details are on the consultation page.

30 minutes · Voice

Audio consultation

RUB 5,000
30 minutes · spoken answers

Conducted by telephone or Telegram to provide spoken answers on applicable statutory rules, procedural deadlines, and immediate safe steps without prior document review or a written opinion.

60 minutes · Video call

Video consultation

RUB 15,000
60 minutes · online meeting

A one-hour spoken strategy discussion during an online video meeting, covering judicial prospects, procedural options, and terms for ongoing case management without prior review of extensive case files.

Independent third opinion · PDF

Case review & third opinion

RUB 25,000
written PDF opinion · up to 100 pages

Independent audit of a matter already handled by counsel, or detailed examination of submitted case materials (tax audit report, claim, contracts) with a written legal opinion and action plan in PDF format.

01a · Monthly Case Management, Strategy & Coordination

Ongoing Case Leadership & Defense Coordination (from RUB 60,000 per month)

When a business needs a lead strategist and coordinator rather than isolated paperwork, representation is structured as a monthly retainer: the attorney builds the legal position, coordinates in-house counsel and accounting, monitors procedural deadlines, and represents the client in commercial court.

Corporate Bankruptcy · Litigation

Case Management, Strategy & Coordination

from RUB 60,000
per month · case coordination

Monthly representation of a corporate debtor or creditor in bankruptcy proceedings or commercial disputes: strategy design, coordination of in-house lawyers and accountants, creditor meetings, and director protection.

Tax & Criminal Defense Contour

Field Tax Audit Accompaniment & Coordination

from RUB 100,000
per month · field audit defense

Monthly accompaniment of field tax audits (including acute phases with criminal prosecution risk under Article 199 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation): unified legal position, responses to tax demands, remote witness preparation, and defense coordination.

T-08 · Full Court Procedure Cycle

Personal Bankruptcy Representation in Commercial Court

RUB 175,000
full judicial cycle

Full-cycle representation of an individual in commercial court bankruptcy proceedings until final debt discharge ruling (statutory RUB 25,000 court deposit is paid separately to the court).

01b · Standalone Procedural Documents (Article 25 of Federal Law No. 63-FZ · Exempt from Value-Added Tax)

Single Procedural Document Drafting Without Monthly Representation (RUB 35,000 – 100,000)

Where ongoing monthly case management is not required and only a single standalone procedural document is needed (RUB 35,000 – 100,000 under mandates T-04 – T-07), fixed fees apply under the signed Legal Assistance Agreement with online payment via the Faster Payments System or bank card through LLC “Bank Tochka”.

T-04 · Up to 3 business days

Statement of Claim / Defense Brief / Tax Demand Response

RUB 35,000
per document · up to 100 pages

Statement of claim or statement of defense in commercial court (Articles 125 and 131 of the Arbitrazh Procedure Code of the Russian Federation), reasoned response to a tax authority request (Articles 88, 93, and 93.1 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation), bankruptcy petition, creditor register claim, or complaint against a trustee.

T-05 · Up to 5 business days

Appellate or Cassation Appeal / Settlement Agreement

RUB 50,000
per filing · up to 100 pages

Drafting an appellate or cassation appeal to a commercial court, a bankruptcy settlement agreement, or a personal debt restructuring plan (up to 1 volume or 100 pages).

T-06 · Up to 5 business days

Tax Audit Objections / Bankruptcy Clawback Filing

RUB 75,000
per filing · up to 100 pages

Written objections to a desk or field tax audit report (Article 100(6) of the Tax Code), complaint against actions or omissions of tax officials, or bankruptcy clawback challenge or defense under Articles 61.2 and 61.3 of the Bankruptcy Law.

T-07 · Up to 7 business days

Subsidiary Liability Defense / Field Tax Appeal / Supreme Court

RUB 100,000
per filing · up to 200 pages

Defense brief against subsidiary liability (Chapter III.2 of the Bankruptcy Law) or director damages, appeal against a field tax audit decision, or Supreme Court cassation appeal.

Base rates

Hourly rate

Hour of expert work

Case review, analytical work with databases and case law, strategy development, ad hoc consultations outside a fixed engagement.

RUB 15,000 per hour
Monthly retainer · Defense coordinator

Field tax audit accompaniment & defense coordination

Lead defense coordinator during an on-site tax audit (including the acute phase with a risk of criminal proceedings): unified legal position, responses to tax demands, remote witness preparation, and coordination of in-house counsel.

from RUB 100,000 per month

Engagement models

Work on complex disputes is structured around four standard engagement formats, each governed by a fixed fee for predictability while the success fee captures the upside on amounts preserved.

Engagement 1 · Monthly case leadership

Case management, strategy & coordination

Ongoing monthly accompaniment of corporate bankruptcy, commercial, or corporate disputes: designing the defense strategy, directing in-house legal and accounting teams, preparing key submissions, and representing the client in court.

from RUB 60,000 per month
Retainer
Engagement 2 · Acute phase & defense coordination

Field tax audit accompaniment & coordination

Monthly retainer accompaniment during an on-site tax audit, including the acute phase with a risk of criminal proceedings under Article 199 of the Criminal Code. Strategic coordination of responses to tax demands, audit objections, remote witness preparation, and in-house legal teams without per-day travel billing.

from RUB 100,000 per month
Retainer
Engagement 3 · Litigation

Project-based court defense

Bankruptcy proceedings, subsidiary liability claims against directors and beneficiaries, appeals of tax-authority decisions. Base fee covers preparation and representation for one court instance.

Success fee: 3-10% of the amount preserved (reduction of additional tax assessment, claims dismissed, subsidiary liability not imposed).

RUB 500,000 — 1,500,000
Per instance
Engagement 4 · Preventive

Preventive capital protection

Long-term phased engagement focused on isolating beneficiary assets from corporate, tax, and subsidiary-liability risks through closed-end mutual investment funds, personal foundations, and other legitimate vehicles.

RUB 1,000,000 — 3,000,000
Project

How the success fee is calculated

The success fee is paid on amounts with a clear monetary measurement, confirmed by a final judicial act or a decision of the tax authority:

The success fee is documented in a separate annex to the engagement contract, with explicit identification of the amount to which the percentage applies. Payment occurs after the relevant judicial act enters legal force.

Principles of financial decisions

Principle 1

A defense budget is rational when it sits at 5-15% of the realistic expected loss. Anything substantially below underweights the risk; anything above is rarely commercial.

Principle 2

Where the result is monetarily measurable, the economic value is split: a base fee covers the work done; the success fee captures the value of the result.

Principle 3

An independent third opinion or initial strategy consultation removes information asymmetry: the client understands the realistic risk distribution and defense roadmap before committing to a long-term litigation budget.

Frequently asked

How is the budget for legal defense calculated?

As a share of the mathematical expectation of losses — the realistic estimate of the financial damage the client may incur. A reasonable defense budget is 5-15% of that expected loss. The remaining value is captured through the success fee on amounts preserved.

Is a success fee permitted in tax and bankruptcy matters?

Yes. Russian law and case law allow a success fee in civil and tax matters when the result has a measurable monetary value: amounts removed from additional tax assessments, claims dismissed in bankruptcy, subsidiary liability not imposed. The success fee is documented separately and paid after the result is confirmed by a final judicial act.

Is the initial consultation or third-opinion fee credited toward ongoing case management?

Yes. The fee for the initial consultation or written third opinion (RUB 25,000) is credited in full toward the first stage of monthly case management or project defense if an agreement is concluded within 14 days.

Are there fixed fees instead of hourly rates, and how is payment made?

Yes. Initial engagements (audio consultation RUB 5,000, video consultation RUB 15,000, document review RUB 25,000) are paid online by bank card (Mir, Visa, Mastercard) or via the Faster Payments System through the internet acquiring service of LLC "Bank Tochka", or by bank transfer against an invoice under the Terms of Website Use, Engagement, and Payment Rules. Cancellations made at least 24 hours prior to a spoken consultation or before document review begins are refunded in full. For court defense and ongoing crisis management, work is structured around fixed engagement fees.

Intake & Document Reception

Submit an Inquiry or Documents for Review

Describe the situation and select the desired engagement format: oral consultation (RUB 5,000 – 15,000), independent third opinion in PDF (RUB 25,000), or monthly case management and coordination (from RUB 60,000 per month).

Files may be attached for preliminary orientation; a standalone written legal opinion (independent third opinion in PDF, up to 1 volume or 100 pages) is RUB 25,000 and is credited toward ongoing case management. Files may also be sent via Telegram Bot @fishchuk_pravo_bot, directly on Telegram @afischuk, on Max +7 (926) 004-78-37, or by email to office@fishchuk.pro.